The Best Auto Repair in Bay Shore, NY

Compare the highest-rated general auto repair mechanics in Bay Shore, New York. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.

#1

Bay Shore Automotive

4.8
(280 reviews)
Verified

A highly reputable, family-owned and operated shop known for its honest diagnostics, exceptional customer service, and technical expertise. They specialize in both domestic and import vehicles and are praised for their transparency and fair pricing.

70 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Specialties & Features

Engine diagnostics
Transmission service
Electrical system repair

Business Information

Years in Business:25 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#2

Pete's Auto Repair

4.7
(180 reviews)
Verified

A well-established local shop with a strong focus on comprehensive auto repair and preventative maintenance. Customers consistently highlight the shop's reliability, skilled technicians, and ability to handle complex repair jobs efficiently.

1095 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Specialties & Features

Brake system service
Engine repair
Routine maintenance

Business Information

Years in Business:20 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#3

Mr. Muffler & Brake

4.6
(150 reviews)
Verified

While the name suggests a specialization, this provider is a full-service auto repair center offering a wide range of services beyond exhaust and brakes. They are known for their quick and accurate diagnostics, quality workmanship, and competitive pricing on everything from oil changes to major repairs.

875 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Specialties & Features

Brake service
Air conditioning repair
Oil changes
maintenance

Business Information

Years in Business:15 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes

Why These Are the Top General Auto Repair Auto Repair Shops in Bay Shore

** The general auto repair market in Bay Shore, New York, is robust and highly competitive, characterized by a mix of long-standing, family-owned shops and larger, multi-service chains. The average quality is high, as the longevity of many businesses indicates a reliance on repeat customers and community reputation. Consumers in this area have access to a wide range of expertise, particularly for both domestic and import vehicles. Pricing is typical for Long Island, which is generally above the national average due to higher overhead and labor costs; however, the competitive nature of the market helps keep prices fair. Customers in Bay Shore tend to value trust and reliability highly, leading to strong loyalty for shops that demonstrate consistent, honest service. The presence of several ASE-Certified technicians across these top shops ensures a high standard of diagnostic capability and repair quality for the community.

High Ratings

4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews

Fully Licensed

All shops are properly licensed and insured

Proven Experience

10+ years average experience in the industry

Local Experts

Familiar with Bay Shore regulations and climate