The Best Auto Repair in Spencer, NY

Compare the highest-rated general auto repair mechanics in Spencer, New York. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.

#1

Spencer Auto Repair

4.7
(85 reviews)
Verified

A well-regarded, locally-owned full-service auto repair shop located directly in the village of Spencer. They are known for their honest diagnostics, reliable work, and strong focus on customer service for both domestic and import vehicles.

19 N Madison St, Spencer, NY 14883

Specialties & Features

Engine diagnostics
Brake system service
Electrical system repair

Business Information

Years in Business:15 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#2

Mathews Auto Service

4.8
(150 reviews)
Verified

A highly reputable, family-owned auto repair center located in nearby Newfield, frequently serving customers from Spencer and the wider Tioga County area. They are praised for their technical expertise, transparency, and quality of workmanship.

218 Main St, Newfield, NY 14867

Specialties & Features

Transmission service
Engine repair
Routine maintenance

Business Information

Years in Business:20 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#3

CPR Automotive

4.6
(200 reviews)
Verified

A well-established and highly-rated automotive service center in nearby Ithaca, known for its comprehensive diagnostic capabilities and professional service. They serve a wide clientele, including those from surrounding towns like Spencer, for complex repair needs.

714 W Court St, Ithaca, NY 14850

Specialties & Features

Electrical system diagnostics
Air conditioning and heating repair
Engine diagnostics

Business Information

Years in Business:25 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes

Why These Are the Top General Auto Repair Auto Repair Shops in Spencer

** The general auto repair market in and around Spencer, NY, is characterized by a small number of highly trusted, independent shops rather than a high volume of competitive chains. As a rural community, the market relies heavily on reputation, longevity, and word-of-mouth. The average quality of service is high, with shops often building multi-generational client relationships. Competition is not intense in terms of quantity but is strong regarding quality and trustworthiness. Pricing is generally competitive and fair for the region, often perceived as more affordable than in larger nearby cities like Ithaca, though labor rates can vary. Customers typically prioritize reliable and honest service over price-shopping, leading to strong customer loyalty for the top providers. For more specialized or complex diagnostics, residents are willing to travel to established shops in Ithaca.

High Ratings

4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews

Fully Licensed

All shops are properly licensed and insured

Proven Experience

10+ years average experience in the industry

Local Experts

Familiar with Spencer regulations and climate