Compare the highest-rated jeep repair mechanics in Shelter Island, New York. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
As the primary full-service automotive shop physically located on Shelter Island, they are the first and most convenient stop for island residents. They handle a wide range of general repairs and maintenance but have specific expertise in the 4WD systems common on Jeeps used for local terrain and launching boats. Their strength is in diagnostics, general repair, and serving the year-round community.
Located in Riverhead, this is the most dedicated and highly-regarded Jeep and off-road specialist serving the Long Island East End, including Shelter Island. Customers specifically cite their work on Wranglers and Gladiators for suspension lifts, performance upgrades, and complex drivetrain work. Their reputation for quality installation and technical knowledge makes them a destination shop for serious Jeep owners.
A well-established and reputable shop in Southampton that provides comprehensive service for all makes and models, with a noted specialization in 4WD and AWD systems. They are a trusted name for complex diagnostics, engine work, and transfer case/differential service on Jeep vehicles. They blend dealership-level technical expertise with independent shop service.
** The Jeep repair market for Shelter Island is a hybrid model defined by geography. The on-island option (**Shelter Island Auto & Marine**) provides essential convenience and reliable general repair but is not a dedicated modification center. The high-end, specialized Jeep market is almost entirely served by off-island specialists on the North and South Forks, with **East End 4x4 & Off-Road Center** being the premier destination for modifications and performance upgrades, and **Precision Auto & 4WD** serving as the top choice for advanced diagnostics and complex mechanical repairs. Competition is moderate but specialized; customers seeking basic service have a local option, while those requiring expert-level work have a clear, albeit ferry-accessible, choice. Pricing reflects the Hamptons-area cost of living and the specialized nature of the services. Labor rates are premium, but the quality of work from the top providers is consistently reported to be high, justifying the cost for owners of valuable Jeeps and Gladiators.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All shops are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Shelter Island regulations and climate