Compare the highest-rated subaru repair mechanics in Athens, Illinois. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
A highly respected, family-owned auto repair shop located right in Athens. They are known for their honest diagnostics and ability to work on a wide range of vehicles, including Japanese brands like Subaru. While not a Subaru-exclusive specialist, their reputation for quality work on complex engine and drivetrain systems makes them the primary local choice for Athens residents.
Located in the nearby and larger town of Petersburg, Tom's Automotive is a well-established shop known for its technical expertise. Customer reviews frequently highlight their experience with Subaru models, including tackling common issues like head gaskets and performing specialized AWD and brake services. They are a go-to for more complex Subaru repairs beyond basic maintenance.
Based in Springfield, this is the premier Subaru-specific specialist in the region. Although a 20-minute drive from Athens, they are worth the trip for owners of newer, turbocharged, or complex Subarus (WRX/STI, Ascent, Outback XT). They explicitly advertise expertise in Subaru-specific repairs, including engine rebuilds, turbo services, and advanced diagnostics that general shops may not have the tools or training for.
** The Subaru repair market in Athens, Illinois, is characteristic of a small rural community. There is a strong reliance on a single, reputable local shop (D&R Auto Service) for most general maintenance and common repairs. For more specialized services—particularly those requiring specific proprietary tools or deep model-specific knowledge (like EyeSight calibration or complex turbocharger work)—residents must look to shops in nearby larger towns like Petersburg and Springfield. **Average Quality:** The quality is bifurcated. General maintenance and common repairs (oil changes, brakes, head gaskets) are handled competently by local mechanics. However, for advanced, model-specific issues, the expertise is concentrated in Springfield, home to the region's only self-identified Subaru specialist (Six Star Auto Service). **Competition Level:** Competition is low within Athens itself but increases when considering the broader Springfield metropolitan area. The local shop does not face direct competition from another dedicated auto repair facility within the village limits. Their main competition comes from dealerships and specialized independents in Springfield. **Typical Pricing:** Pricing is generally competitive and often more affordable than dealership rates. A local shop like D&R Auto Service may charge $90-$110/hr for labor, while a specialist like Six Star Auto Service may command $120-$140/hr due to their specialized tooling, training, and expertise. Head gasket replacement jobs on a Subaru EJ25 engine typically range from $2,200 to $3,200 in this market, depending on the shop and whether additional engine work is performed while it is disassembled.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All shops are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Athens regulations and climate