Compare the highest-rated subaru repair mechanics in Mattoon, Illinois. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
A & W is consistently highlighted in local reviews as the premier independent shop for complex diagnostics and repair. They have built a strong reputation for tackling advanced Subaru-specific issues that other local shops may turn away. Customers frequently mention their honesty, thoroughness, and ability to solve persistent problems.
Known for their modern diagnostic equipment and highly trained technicians, Mattoon Car Care is a top contender for routine and complex Subaru maintenance. They receive positive mentions for servicing newer models with EyeSight and CVT transmissions, indicating they invest in the necessary tools and training.
As a national chain with a strong local presence, Firestone offers a compelling option for more standard Subaru services. Their strengths lie in routine maintenance, tire services for the Symmetrical AWD system, and multi-point inspections. For highly specialized work like major engine rebuilds, they may be less suited than the independent specialists above, but they provide reliable, accessible service.
** The Subaru repair market in Mattoon is characterized by a handful of highly competent independent shops rather than a dense competitive landscape. The absence of a dedicated Subaru-exclusive tuner or specialist means that the top providers are generalists who have chosen to master the brand's complexities. **A & W Automotive** stands out as the de facto specialist for major engine and drivetrain work, while **Mattoon Car Care** positions itself as the go-to for advanced electronics and transmission systems. **Firestone** captures the market for convenience and routine care. Overall service quality among the top-tier providers is high, with a strong emphasis on customer service and building long-term trust. Pricing is competitive and generally lower than dealership rates in larger nearby cities like Champaign or Effingham, making Mattoon a cost-effective location for Subaru owners seeking quality repairs. For the most niche services (e.g., dedicated STI performance tuning or Crosstrek Hybrid system diagnostics), owners would likely need to travel to a metropolitan center.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All shops are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Mattoon regulations and climate