The Best Subaru Repair in Middletown, IN

Compare the highest-rated subaru repair mechanics in Middletown, Indiana. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.

#1

Tom's Auto Service & Repair

4.8
(280 reviews)
Verified

A highly reputable, family-owned shop known for its honest diagnostics and expertise with Japanese imports. While not exclusively a Subaru specialist, their lead technicians have extensive experience with the Subaru boxer engine platform, AWD systems, and common issues like head gasket failures. They are a top-tier independent alternative to the dealership.

1224 Columbus Ave, Anderson, IN 46012 (Approx. 8 miles from Middletown)

Specialties & Features

Boxer engine service
Head gasket replacement
AWD diagnostics

Business Information

Years in Business:18 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#2

Jolly's Service Center

4.6
(190 reviews)
Verified

A well-established service center with a strong local presence. Reviews frequently highlight their competence with complex drivetrain issues. They have invested in advanced diagnostic equipment capable of servicing modern Subarus, including initial diagnostics for the EyeSight system before referring to a dealer for final calibration.

203 E 53rd St, Anderson, IN 46013 (Approx. 7 miles from Middletown)

Specialties & Features

AWD system service
CVT maintenance
Turbo system service

Business Information

Years in Business:22 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#3

Midas of Anderson

4.4
(150 reviews)
Verified

As part of a national chain, this location benefits from corporate training programs, standardized procedures, and access to specialized tools. They are a reliable option for routine Subaru-specific maintenance like CVT fluid changes and brake services on Symmetrical AWD systems. For highly complex issues like hybrid systems or major engine rebuilds, they may recommend the dealership.

2910 Columbus Ave, Anderson, IN 46012 (Approx. 9 miles from Middletown)

Specialties & Features

CVT maintenance
Routine service
Brake
AWD service

Business Information

Years in Business:12 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes

Why These Are the Top Subaru Repair Auto Repair Shops in Middletown

** The Subaru repair market in the immediate Middletown area is characterized by limited specialized options, necessitating a short commute to Anderson for quality service. The market in Anderson is moderately competitive, with a mix of long-standing independent shops and national chains vying for customers. * **Average Quality:** The average quality for general auto repair is good, but true, deep Subaru specialization (particularly for EyeSight calibration and hybrid systems) is concentrated at the dealership level in larger cities like Muncie or Indianapolis. The top independents, like those listed, offer excellent value and expertise for mechanical repairs but may defer to dealers for advanced ADAS work. * **Competition Level:** Moderate. Customers have a choice between trusted locals and branded chains, which helps maintain reasonable pricing and service standards. * **Typical Pricing:** Labor rates in the Anderson area are generally 15-25% lower than in metropolitan areas like Indianapolis. A typical head gasket replacement on a Subaru 2.5L engine may range from $2,200 - $3,000, while a CVT fluid exchange typically costs between $250 - $400. It is crucial for owners to get explicit quotes for Subaru-specific services, as the procedures and fluids are often more specialized and costly than for conventional vehicles. For the most complex services like **EyeSight calibration** and **Crosstrek Hybrid system service**, the required proprietary software and tools almost always mean a visit to the authorized Subaru dealership, which for this region is typically **Tom Wood Subaru** in Indianapolis or a dealer in Muncie.

High Ratings

4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews

Fully Licensed

All shops are properly licensed and insured

Proven Experience

10+ years average experience in the industry

Local Experts

Familiar with Middletown regulations and climate