The Best Subaru Repair in Plymouth, WI
Compare the highest-rated subaru repair mechanics in Plymouth, Wisconsin. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
Don Johnson's Tire & Auto
A long-standing, family-owned pillar of the Plymouth community, Don Johnson's has built a formidable reputation for honesty and technical expertise. While not an exclusive Subaru shop, their master technicians have extensive experience with the brand's unique engineering. They are a top-tier independent alternative to the dealership, frequently praised for diagnosing complex issues others miss, particularly with the Boxer engine and AWD system.
Specialties & Features
Business Information
Ziegler Auto of Plymouth
As the area's authorized Subaru dealership, Ziegler Auto is the default choice for warranty work, complex electronic systems, and factory-recalled repairs. Their technicians receive direct factory training and have exclusive access to Subaru's proprietary diagnostic tools and software. This makes them the most qualified provider for EyeSight calibration and CVT transmission software updates. They also service the Crosstrek Hybrid.
Specialties & Features
Business Information
Dave's Auto Service
Dave's is a smaller, highly-focused independent shop known for its personalized service and deep mechanical expertise. Owner Dave Gartman and his team have a strong following among local Subaru owners who seek out their knowledge for engine rebuilds, turbo system service (WRX/STI), and preventative maintenance. They are renowned for their meticulous workmanship and fair pricing.
Specialties & Features
Business Information
Why These Are the Top Subaru Repair Auto Repair Shops in Plymouth
** The Subaru repair market in Plymouth, WI, is characteristic of a smaller Midwestern city. The quality of service is generally high, driven by a community that values reliability and long-term business relationships. The competition level is moderate, with a clear hierarchy: the dealership (**Ziegler Auto**) handles the most specialized, technology-driven work, while two highly-trusted independents (**Don Johnson's** and **Dave's Auto Service**) dominate the market for mechanical repairs and diagnostics. Pricing follows this structure, with dealership labor rates and parts costs being the highest. The independent shops offer significant cost savings (typically 15-30% lower labor rates) while maintaining excellent quality for all mechanical aspects of Subaru repair. For a Subaru owner in Plymouth, the choice often comes down to the nature of the job: dealership for electronics, calibrations, and warranty; independents for engines, transmissions, and general maintenance. There is no single shop that exclusively specializes in all Subaru systems, but this trio provides comprehensive coverage for the brand.
High Ratings
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
Fully Licensed
All shops are properly licensed and insured
Proven Experience
10+ years average experience in the industry
Local Experts
Familiar with Plymouth regulations and climate