The Best Toyota Repair in Hortonville, NY

Compare the highest-rated toyota repair mechanics in Hortonville, New York. All shops are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.

#1

Liberty Auto Care

4.8
(180 reviews)
Verified

A highly-rated independent shop known for its technical expertise with Japanese imports, especially Toyota and Lexus. The technicians have prior dealership experience and advanced training. They are a top choice for complex diagnostics, hybrid system service, and engine work, offering dealership-level quality at more competitive rates.

198 Old Rte 17, Liberty, NY 12754

Specialties & Features

Toyota/Hybrid system diagnostics
Engine repair (2.5L
3.5L V6)
CVT/automatic transmission service

Business Information

Years in Business:12 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#2

Monticello Tire & Auto Center

4.5
(110 reviews)
Verified

A well-established, full-service auto center that has served Sullivan County for decades. They have multiple ASE-certified technicians and invest in modern diagnostic tools. They are a reliable option for general Toyota maintenance, electrical issues, AWD system service, and transmission work.

445 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

Specialties & Features

Transmission service
Electrical system diagnostics
4WD and AWD system maintenance

Business Information

Years in Business:25 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes
#3

Sullivan Auto Repair

4.6
(90 reviews)
Verified

A smaller, reputable shop known for its honest service and focus on customer satisfaction. They handle a wide range of repairs from routine maintenance to more complex engine and drivetrain work on Toyota models. Their strength lies in personalized service and building long-term relationships with clients.

221 Jefferson St, Monticello, NY 12701

Specialties & Features

Engine repair
Toyota-certified diagnostics
General maintenance
repairs

Business Information

Years in Business:15 years
Licensed:Yes
Insured:Yes

Why These Are the Top Toyota Repair Auto Repair Shops in Hortonville

** The Toyota repair market for Hortonville and the surrounding Sullivan County area is characterized by a handful of high-quality independent shops rather than a dense competitive landscape. There are no Toyota dealerships immediately in Hortonville or the closest towns like Liberty or Monticello; residents typically travel to Middletown or further for dealership service. This has fostered a strong market for independent specialists who can provide dealership-level expertise. The average quality of these top independent shops is very high, as evidenced by their strong reviews and longevity. Pricing is generally more competitive than dealership rates, often 20-30% lower for labor, while using the same or equivalent OEM-quality parts. For highly specialized services, particularly deep hybrid system repairs or TRD performance upgrades, a trip to a dedicated dealership or performance shop in a larger city like Middletown may still be necessary.

High Ratings

4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews

Fully Licensed

All shops are properly licensed and insured

Proven Experience

10+ years average experience in the industry

Local Experts

Familiar with Hortonville regulations and climate